I am amazed at the quantity of music notation software available on the market. The two most popular products, Finale and Sibelius, get most of my attention. However, there are many, many more titles from which to choose. A wonderful comprehensive list of music notation products is available at:
http://ace.acadiau.ca/score/others.htm
If you peruse the extensive list of notation programs on this site, you will note quite a few free notation programs.

Finale NotePad
The free notation program that I use most is Finale NotePad www.finalenotepad.com. It is a free download and a lite version of Finale. Finale NotePad 2008 added step entry via MIDI making it a viable option to use to communicate with other programs, as it will also export files in MIDI format. For a complete list of the features check out:
http://www.finalemusic.com/Notepad/New.aspx

The only major problem with Finale NotePad is that files are not backwardly compatible in Finale format. So, for example, you can’t open a Finale NotePad 2008 file in an earlier version of Finale. However, you can download earlier versions of Finale NotePad by searching the downloads section of the Finale Notepad website:
http://www.finalemusic.com/store/search.aspx

Opening Finale Files in NotePad
Finale NotePad can open Finale files. This makes it possible to create a file in Finale and then have others open it for playback and practice in Finale Notepad. I also find that Finale NotePad is a good place to start when teaching students how to use Finale. There is a limited number of tools.

Once students have the hang of NotePad, moving to Finale is a snap. There are some excellent tutorials that ship with Finale NotePad. From the Help menu, choose Tutorials.

Another free program that I have used is Nightingale Light
http://www.ngale.com/index_04.html

How are you or your students using Finale NotePad?

What other free notation software have you found helpful?

There are several ways to share files between Finale and Sibelius music notation software. One option is to save the file in MIDI format and open it in the other application. The problem with MIDI files (Standard MIDI File Format) is they only transmit performance information such as pitches, rhythms, time signatures, and the like. Text elements such as chord symbols and lyrics and page layout formats are not captured in MIDI files.

MusicXML
The answer to this problem is MusicXML. The Recodare company www.recordare.com introduced MusicXML as a way to translate music notation from one application to the other. With MusicXML, in addition to the notation, the text elements are also translated (XML stands for eXtensible Markup Language and is used for a wide variety of software applications). The translation is not 100% as there will be some minor editing but it is much better than sharing MIDI files. See the screen shot of the first few bars of a piece that was entered in Finale, saved in MusicXML format and opened in Sibelius 5. The lyrics and text all came over with only minor editing required.

File entered in Finale and saved in MusicXML format:

MusicXML file opened in Sibelius 5:

Finale and MusicXML
Finale 2006 and later versions include the option to save and open MusicXML file formats. Simply choose File > Save Special and select the desired option. This allows Finale users to send their files to Sibelius users. MusicXML is also the best way to share Finale files with older versions of the software, as Finale versions are not backward compatible. So, if you want to share your Finale 2008 with an earlier version, saving the file in MusicXML is the way to go. Using MusicXML you can backwards save to Finale 2000 on Windows or Finale 2004 on Mac OS X. With versions that do not include the MusicXML export/import option you will need to download and purchase a plug-in from Recordare.com. The current version, Finale 2008, comes with the capability of saving and exporting MusicXML files.

Sibelius and MusicXML
Sibelius 4 and 5 can open MusicXML files. So, a Finale user can send a file to be opened in Sibelius. However, Sibelius 4 and 5 do not include an option to export MusicXML. So, in order for Sibelus to export music XML, you will need to purchase the “Dolet” plug-in from www.recodare.com. The plug-in for Sibelius is not cheap, but it does provide the capability of saving files to share with Finale users.

Other applications of MusicXML
Check out the Recordare website for a listing of applications that support MusicXML including Cubase and others:
www.recordare.com/xml/software.html

The technology of scanning converts a piece of sheet music into a digital media that can be read by music software. Scanning, the musical version of OCR (optical character recognition) has been around for years. The technology has come of age and is a viable way to input music from printed sheet music into music software in general and music notation software in particular.

Why Use Scanning Technology?
If you are using music production software then you might be interested in scanning technology so you can take a piece of printed music, say a bass or piano part, and scan and convert it into a sequence. The more common use of scanning technology is to save time inputting notation into Finale or Sibelius or other music notation software. Scanning can be a fast way to input parts from printed sheet music.

Three Scanning Technology Options
There are currently three scanning technologies. They include:

1. SmartScore Lite and SmartScore Pro – for Mac and Windows computers and is integrated with Finale Notation software
2. PhotoScore and PhotoScore Ultimate – for Mac and Windows computers and is integrated with Sibelius notation software
3. SharpEye – for Windows computers. The software costs $169.00 and SharpEye Music Reader converts a scanned image of printed music into a MIDI file, a NIFF file, or a Music XML file.

Required Hardware
You will need a flatbed scanner to scan the sheet music you want to convert. You don’t need a high-end scanner since music is typically scanned in black and white or grayscale and at a relatively low DPI (dots per inch) of 300. Most scanners will work for this purpose. Do check with the software company’s website for recommended scanners. I have had good success with Canon and Epson scanners. The one I am currently using is a Canon CanoScan LiDE 25 that I paid less than $50 for. It is a no-frills scanner, but does the job nonetheless.

Sibelius’ recommendations for scanners
SmartScore’s recommendations

Sibelius = PhotoScore
Sibelius ships with a free, lite version of PhotoScore. This version can do basic scanning, but there are significant limits. For example, the current shipped version does not recognize triplets. So, if you want the most powerful scanning option for Sibelius, I recommend that you purchase the full version of the software, PhotoScore Ultimate.
There is an excellent help file posted in the Sibelius website, written by Bruce Munson.

Finale = SmartScore
Finale notation software ships with a lite version of SmartScore. You will get much more accurate results if you upgrade to the full version of SmartScore Pro. The best place to get familiar with scanning in Finale is to view the tutorial video. Launch Finale. From the Help menu, choose QuickStart Videos. Then select Getting Started > Importing Music > Scanning.

Scanning to MIDI
If you want to convert sheet music to MIDI to import into Music Production Software, then scanning software can be a solution for you. There are several options to choose from including Musitech’s MIDI Edition and Neutron’s PhotoScore MIDI.

It may take some time to get the right hardware and tweak the software settings to get accurate results with scanning. I have found it is worth the effort.

One of the most common questions I am asked regarding music notation software note entry is “why can’t I just play in the parts with my MIDI keyboard in one pass in real-time?” Since most people use notation software with the goal of printing scores and parts, you have to approach real-time note entry with care. Here are some tips to playing in real-time with Finale and Sibelius or other music notation software.

Stack the Deck in your Favor (quantization)
Learn to get under the hood of your software and check the settings when playing in real-time. Sibelius refers to is as Flexi-Time and Finale calls it HyperScribe. I recommend you read the reference manual, watch the tutorial videos, or, if you have a book on Finale or Sibelius (see links on this page), check out the chapters dedicated to playing in real time. When you open the settings in Sibelius (Notes Menu > Flexi-time Options) or Finale (MIDI menu > Quantization) be sure to set the notation level to the smallest note value in the piece or passage you are playing. For example, in the first example below, the smallest note value is an eighth note. Are there triplets or other tuplets? If not, turn them off. This will make the notation interpretation by the software more accurate.

Metronome Tempo
The metronome setting may also affect your accuracy. Try setting the tempo to a relatively slow tempo. After the notation is entered, you can always speed it up. I have also found that setting the metronome to the eighth note can also help real-time entry accuracy. In Finale, this is set in the HyperScribe menu > Beat Source > Playback and/or Click. In Sibelius, you can change the time signature from 4/4 to 8/8 to have the eighth note as the beat.

MIDI Technique
I am not a keyboard player by trade. I have functional keyboard skills that I use primarily to enter notes into notation software. Music technologist, author, and educator, Don Muro, recommends developing MIDI technique. MIDI technique is not like playing legato, where you connect notes as you play; nor is it like staccato playing where there is a noticeable space between each note. MIDI technique, as Don explained it to me, is playing one note and then immediately playing the next note.

Here are some exercises to help develop your “MIDI technique:”
1. Set the minimum duration to an eighth note; turn off all triplets
2. Set the tempo in a comfortable range, such as 76
3. Play the following exercise.
If you make mistakes, undo your performance and go back and re-try it.

After you are successful with this exercise, go back and set the minimum duration for the notation to a 16th note and turn off all triplets. Now practice this exercise:

Next, in the settings window, turn on triplets and play this exercise:

With practice, real-time entry may save you time inputting notation into your score.

Sibelius: Flexi-Time
Sibelius has an option where Sibelius follows your tempo as you play. If you slow down or speed up, it attempts to follow you. This can be an effective option if you are improvising, but if you are transcribing a part, I would turn the Flexi part of Flexi-time off (non-rubato). This is found in the Flexi-time Options window.

Finale: HyperScribe
Finale has an option where the player supplies the beat. You can use a foot pedal or MIDI note to control the tempo. This also can be useful in some applications, but for the most part, I recommend playing in with a steady metronome beat. This is set in the HyperScribe menu.

You can also use your Music Production software to enter the notation, save it as a MIDI file and import it into your notation software. Remember, you can use different entry tools. I personally do 90% of my entry using step entry, however, if there is a relatively simple passage with very few rests, I may enter it in real-time.

I am often asked by my students in live and online Sibelius and Finale courses: What is the fastest way to enter notation in notation software? There are five approaches:

1. Click in notes using the mouse

2. Use the Computer numeric keypad and type the letter keys on the keyboard

3. Use a MIDI Keyboard (or MIDI Controller) and enter the notes and rests one at a time.

4. Use a MIDI keyboard (or MIDI controller) and enter the notes in real-time.

5. Import the notation via MIDI files or scanning technology.

In this post I will focus on the first three options, referred to as step-time entry. I use step-time entry when I am copying from a printed score into notation software or entering notation that I have memorized. I also use it when I am copying from one part in a score to another.

Let’s consider each one of the step-time options:

Entering by clicking the notes with the mouse
I rarely use the mouse entry technique for one reason: it is the slowest method of note entry. With Finale and Sibelius, you first click the desired note value and then move the mouse to the staff and click in the pitch. It is OK for beginners and young students, but is it very slow compared to the other notation step-time entry options. I do use this method after a score or part has been entered to edit notation such as adding ties, grace notes, correcting an occasional rhythm, and so forth.

Use the Numeric Keypad
The trick to fast step-time note entry is to use the numeric keypad to select the duration. The mouse is not used except to select the first bar for entering notation. If you are using a laptop, purchase a USB external keypad. They cost approximately $25 and will speed your note entry significantly.

The approach here is to learn to touch-type. Sibelius assigns the number 4 on the numeric keypad for a quarter note. With Finale, the number 5 is a quarter note. Larger numbers = larger values; smaller numbers = smaller values. With some practice you learn to “feel” the note durations. Once you get familiar touch-typing, your entry speed will increase significantly.

Entering with the Alphabetic Letter keys
Both Finale (via Simple Entry) and Sibelius have the option of selecting a note value and then entering the note by typing the letters A through G on the computer keyboard. If I don’t have access to a MIDI keyboard, this is the option that I use. Select the note value on the numeric keypad and then type the letter of the desired pitch. The key to faster entry speed is to use a two-hand approach. Put your right hand over the numeric keypad and your left hand over the alphabetic keys. Select the value with your right hand then type the letter with your left.


(The above graphic is from my Berkleeonline course: Music Notation using Sibelius)

When you type in letter names the octave may not be correct. Use the shortcut to transpose octaves: Sibelius = hold down CTRL (Command on Mac) and press the up or down arrows. With Finale hold the Shift key and use the up or down arrows. How do you enter a rest? Both Finale (in Simple Entry) and Sibelius use the same approach: select the note value on the numeric keypad and press zero on the keypad to enter a rest. To enter chords, both Finale (in Simple Entry) and Sibelius use the same approach: press the number keys across the top of the computer keyboard to enter chords. With a note selected press 3 to add a third above, 5 for a fifth above and so forth. Hold down the Shift key to enter intervals below the selected note.

MIDI Entry
The fastest way to enter notation in step-time is with a MIDI keyboard or controller.

I place one hand on the MIDI keyboard and the other hand over the numeric keypad. Use the mouse only to select the bar. Then, let go of the mouse and select the duration on the numeric keypad and play the note or chord on the MIDI keyboard. If there is a rest, press the zero key on the numeric keypad. Chords are a snap – just play the chord! Also, octaves are not a problem because you can play it on the MIDI keyboard or controller in the proper octave.

Look at the Music/Screen (not your hands)
Next, develop an approach where you are looking a the music notation to be entered and then check computer screen after the note is entered. I place my music stand next to my monitor. Look at the notation to be entered and the touch type to enter it. Then check the computer screen to be sure it was entered correctly. Your hands are working by touch. When I see a mistake, I fix it immediately. Use the undo function that works on most every program CTRL+Z (Windows); Command+Z (Mac).

Use Multiple Approaches
You may find that switching between the various step-time options is beneficial. For example, when I am entering slash notation, it requires entering one pitch for several bars, I will select the quarter note value on the numeric keypad and then press and hold the letter B on the keyboard. Since the computer keyboard repeats, you can enter the same pitch quite fast.

Summary:

1. Use the mouse for note entry sparingly. Use it to select the starting point in your score and for editing after the notation has been entered.

2. Use the numeric keypad to select durations

3. Use a MIDI keyboard or MIDI controller to enter pitches

4. Learn to touch-type and focus your attention on the music and computer screen.

In my next post, I’ll review some tips for entering notation in real-time and for using copy and paste to speed the entry process. What do you find to be the fastest step-time note entry technique?

No matter what notation software you use, Finale, Sibelius, Notion, Overture, or others, you can save your scores in PDF format and share them with others who do not own the software. PDF stands for Portable Document Format and was created by Adobe. It is the standard print format for all applications. A PDF file has the file extension that you would expect: .pdf.

FREE Options…

Mac OSX
If you are using Mac OSX, you can create PDFs from any application. It is built into the operating system. Simply select File > Print and click the PDF button at the bottom of the Print window and select “Save as PDF.” I often save in PDF format to post on web pages and to share with others.

Check out this PDF file I created in Sibelius. It is snare drum exercises my brother John Rudolph created. John plays in the Toronto Symphony.

Windows
Windows does not come with a built-in PDF converter but you can download free programs such as PDF Creator, or PDF995. With your notation software launched and your file of choice open, choose Print from the File menu. Then, select the PDF option you downloaded. I have PDF Creator installed on Windows. It works great.

The option that will cost you money….

The other option is to purchase Acrobat (not Acrobat Reader which is free). The current version is Acrobat Standard 8 which lists for $299.00. It does a lot more than save PDF files. You can open and edit PDF files and more. But, it does have a pretty high price tag.

There are several ways to share your Finale and Sibelius files with others. Of course you can submit your scores for publication the traditional way by contacting music publishers and submitting your scores to them for publication. If you go this route, a good place to find listings of most of the major music publishers is via the Music Publishers Association’s website: www.mpa.org

If you are a Finale or Sibelius user, there are options for posting and sharing your work with others that does not require securing a publisher of your work. Files posted to these sites must be original music or music arranged by the composer that is in public domain. Both sites review the posts and will refuse music posted that is a violation of the copyright law.

Finale Showcase
For Finale users, and users of any of the Finale family software, including the free program Finale Notpad, there is the Finale Showcase. To access the Showcase, go to www.finaleshowcase.com and click on the Showcase tab.

It is free to set-up an account with Finale Showcase. Once the account is setup you can create a personal area to upload and post your files. Files are offered for free to others. The search options on the Finale Showcase are somewhat limited and there is no composer search option. I did a search for Pachelbel Canon, and received several hits. The total number of files on the site is not listed. There is no commercial option on Finale Showcase, but it is a good option for sharing your files with others and download files posted by other users.

Sibeliusmusic.com
If you use Sibelius or Sibelius G7, you can participate in the largest website for posting notation files for others: www.sibeliusmusic.com. As of February 3, 2008, there are more than 75,000 files posted on the site.

Sibeliusmusic.com uses Sibelius’s Scorch technology, which allows Sibelius files to be posted on any website for viewing, saving, and printing. Sibelius users can post files for free or sell them on the site for a profit. When you post files for a fee, you split the profit 50/50 with the Sibelius site. Music can be perused by style including Classical, Pop/Rock, Educational, Worship and Other. You can also find composers alphabetically and search for individual song titles.

Once you register your site on Sibeliusmusic.com, you can include a personal photograph and information about you and your music and links to other sites.
Sibeliusmusic.com offers an enhanced site for monthly cost of $30.00 per month. In return you get a much higher return on sales of your music and merchandise (70% - 80%) and a completely customizable online store to showcase your music, in addition to all the benefits of a self-publisher.

So, take advantage of these two sites to download files from other composers and post your own files.

Looking for ways to learn Finale or Sibelius notation software? Getting familiar with the software and finding ways to get your questions answered are important considerations. Here are some of the options I have found helpful to learn both programs.

Instructional Videos: both Finale 2008 and Sibelius 5 come with video tutorials. Simply launch the software and from the Help menu choose videos. These videos are short tutorials designed to give you some familiarity with specific areas of the program such as note entry, page layout and more. Finale refers to them as QuickStart Videos and Sibelius calls them Tutorial Videos. I recommend watching these videos with the software running. After viewing a technique in a video, press the pause button and then try the steps in Finale or Sibelius

Finale has an especially helpful video called the visual index. Here, you view a graphic of a variety of music notation samples and when you click on something and the appropriate instructional video launches.

Ask Video (www.askvideo.com) has a series of video tutorials on many music programs including Sibelius music notation software.

Reference guide: Both programs have a built-in comprehensive reference guide. Select it from the help menu and it loads in Acrobat Reader. You can click on the index or search for specific information. Both guides offer lots of screen shots and step-by-step instructions. The reference guide is the first place I go when I want the steps for a specific item. For example, if you want to find out how to create a grace note, the fastest way is to search the reference manual.

Website and Voice: Both Finale and Sibelius offer extensive help via their websites. I recommend going to the website if you can’t find the answer using the reference or the tutorial videos. The websites will also mention known problems or bugs with the program. You can search the database of questions and answers. For Sibelius go to www.sibelius.com and click on Help Center. For Finale, go to www.finalemusic.com and click on support and the select Knowledge Base. If you can’t find the answer you are looking for, you can post a question. There is also a third party Finale forum at www.finaleforum.com. If these options don’t get the question answered, then you can call voice support. If you take this step, be sure to have your computer on and the software up and running so you can test out the answers from tech support while on the phone.

Books: There are several books on Finale and Sibelius from various publishers. Books can be helpful when learning software as they typically include more information than videos. The problem with books is they aren’t always up to date with the current version of the software. Hal Leonard, Berklee Press, Thompson and other publishers produce books including Finale Power!, The Finale Primer, Finale an Easy Guide to Music Notation, Sibelius a Comprehensive Guide and others.

Courses (online and classroom): You can take complete courses on Finale and Sibelius at institutions and online. There are 12-week courses on both Finale and Sibelius at www.berkleemusic.com and many classroom courses at a variety of institutions. A good resource for summer workshops in music technology and music notation is available at www.ti-me.org/summer. Also, check the Finale and Sibelius websites for listings of workshops and courses.

There are two main software tools musicians use for creating music: music production software, also called sequencers, and music notation software. Most music software titles designed for composition fall under one of these two main categories. There are many music production software titles from which to choose. It is the most common application used by musicians to compose music and score to film. There are titles both for Windows and Macintosh computers. Some publishers produce cross-platform versions and others specialize only in the Windows or Mac world. Titles include Sonar, Live, Logic, Digital Performer, Pro Tools, Reason, Acid, Cubase, Nuendo, and more. In the notation world there are far fewer options. There are two most popular titles, Finale and Sibelius, and some others including Notion, Overture, and Encore.

The difference between music production and notation software is often confused. When I describe the two, I use this somewhat simplified definition:

When your primary goal is to produce a sound or performance file, use music production software. It functions as a virtual recording studio.

When your primary goal is to produce printed notation, use Notation Software (sometimes referred to as “scoring software”). It functions as a virtual music typewriter or copyist.

The confusing part is music production software will do some decent printing and music notation software can play back and create sound files. Granted some of the high-end music production software titles do include an impressive list of notation options. However, most composers find it best to use notation software for creating and printing scores and parts, such as Finale or Sibelius. Notation programs have many helpful tools for creating scores and parts such as adjusting the look of the printed page, adding text, lyrics, chord symbols, changing the size and shape of the music, creating guitar tab, scanning in printed music and much, much more.

Do you Need Both Music Production and Notation Software?
Most composers who are responsible for both sound and notation, use a music production and a notation program. Other composers who primarily write for print publication spend most of their time in notation software. It is possible to create your music in a music production program, save it in Standard MIDI format and then import the MIDI file into a notation program and use it to create and generate the score and parts. You can also save notation files in MIDI format and send them to your production software to create a sound version.

If you find yourself spending a lot of time in your music production program dealing with the printing of parts, then you may be better off using a notation program such as Finale or Sibelius. The bottom line: use the program that is best suited for a particular purpose: sound = music production software; notation = notation software.